'Very Creepy With the Teeth': A Face in the Frame and Knives That Vanish at Newburgh Brewing
The owner of Newburgh Brewing Company in New York showed News 12 motion-camera captures from his kitchen: a white shape he says turns into a grimacing face, and two overnight flashes 47 minutes apart with pots, a pail, a tray and knives in different places.
Location Newburgh Brewing Company, South Colden Street, Newburgh, New York

NEWBURGH, N.Y. (Oct. 16, 2026): The building on South Colden Street has been a lot of things since the 1850s. A steam engine works. A yarn factory. The Newburgh Paper Box Company. These days, it’s Newburgh Brewing Company. And its owner, Paul Halayko, says the kitchen camera has been picking up things he can’t explain.
Where it started
The original social media post
-
Blaise Gomez, News 12 @BlaiseGomez12 on X
The owner is showing me creepy footage he can’t explain: a face-like shape and kitchen items that appear to change places when no one is there. An exclusive look tonight on @News12HV.
Video from the brewery's kitchen camera
Excerpt from the reporter's post, which went up shortly before the News 12 web story. Owner Paul Halayko says he first shared the footage online himself; we haven't found his original post.
From the conversation
-
Renovation budget should to include hazard pay
-
Posts shown as originally published; we don’t verify individual comments. Retrieved . “Load the post here” fetches the original from X, which may set cookies.
He sat down with News 12 reporter Blaise Gomez, pulled up the images, and pointed at a white shape on the screen.
“Kind of like a grimaced mouth right here,” he said. “Very creepy with the teeth, definitely see two eyes.”
What we know
On the record: documents, statements, dates and places. Sources below.
- The camera. The footage dates to February 2024, after Halayko installed a motion-activated camera in the brewery kitchen, News 12 reported.
- The face. One capture shows a white shape that, Halayko says, turns into a face.
- The flashes. Two other recordings caught flashes of light overnight, about 47 minutes apart, when no one was inside, he says.
- The moving objects. Comparing the frames before and after, Halayko points to pots, a garbage pail, a tray and knives that seem to have moved or disappeared. “We’ve got two knives right there in the middle on the knife rack,” he said. “Now let’s go to the next photo, they are gone.”
- What the footage doesn’t show. News 12 noted that the recordings don’t show any of those items actually moving. A motion camera captures moments, not everything in between.
- The history check. Halayko says he asked the city historian, who found no recorded fatal accidents in the building. She noted that industrial work could be dangerous and that some incidents might never have been written down. News 12 was careful to add that the history “does not establish an explanation for the images.”
What’s claimed
Accounts, testimony and theories, as told by the people who tell them.
- The man in overalls. Halayko says a brewery worker has seen a man in overalls on several occasions, downstairs in the production area. According to Halayko, the worker described the encounters as positive.
- Something paranormal. Halayko isn’t saying it’s a ghost. He isn’t saying it isn’t. “I’d be crazy to say it’s not possible,” he told News 12, “because there are many things in this world that we don’t understand.”
Where it started
Halayko told News 12 he recently shared the kitchen footage online to see what people thought, and the response was huge. We haven’t found his original post. Shortly before the web story ran, Gomez posted the footage on X, and the handful of replies were mostly GIFs. One account, @CSG_Guide, got right to the practical question: “Renovation budget should to include hazard pay.”
The questions
These are still frames from a motion-triggered camera, with gaps between them. The flashes are 47 minutes apart. That leaves a lot of room. The obvious questions, the ones anyone would ask about a working kitchen, are whether someone came through between captures, whether a night shift or cleaning crew moved things, and what set off the camera’s flash in the first place. News 12’s report doesn’t answer them, and Halayko doesn’t claim to know.
What Halayko has is a handful of pictures, a worker’s story about a friendly man in overalls, and a building with 170 years of history nobody fully wrote down. For a brewery heading into October, that’s not a bad thing to have.
Sources
- Ghosts in the kitchen? Newburgh brewery owner shares eerie security footage (opens in new tab) · News 12 Blaise Gomez, Oct. 16, 2026, 12:36 p.m. ET. Source of all Halayko quotes.