A Voice in the Timber, a Friend Who Changed: A Western Montana Hunting Story
A hunter writes that in late October a friend radioed that he had heard the writer calling his name from the trees, though the writer says they never spoke. No recording exists and the friend has not told his side.
Location Western Montana; forest not named

Two hunters, a couple of hundred yards of thick pine and brush between them, and a pair of walkie-talkies. That is the setup of a story posted to Reddit’s r/Paranormal on the evening of November 12, 2026 by u/ElMattew, who says it happened “about two weeks ago, around the end of October,” in the woods of western Montana.
Where it started
The original social media post
-
u/ElMattew on Reddit
This happened about two weeks ago, around the end of October and I’m still pretty confused, turning it over in my head without knowing what to think.
One writer's account, including what a friend reportedly heard. There is no recording.
From the conversation
-
I wonder if it was a bird like a starling or mockingbird? They can mimic humans and it can be really alarming to hear them.
-
I would definitely have a few drinks with him so he’s loose relaxed and talkative then ask him about what exactly happened and how he knows the nickname he called you […]
-
The nickname part really gets to me. I hope you find out more about his experience.
-
Posts shown as originally published; we don’t verify individual comments. Retrieved . “Load the post here” fetches the original from Reddit, which may set cookies.
The writer says they never pressed the transmit button. Their friend says he heard the writer’s voice calling his name from the trees anyway. Everything after that is one person’s telling, with no recording and no word yet from the friend.
The radio
According to the post, the two drove out early in the friend’s truck, hiked a couple of miles, and split up as the sun dropped, each climbing a deer stand “only 200 or 300 yards apart.” For a few hours, nothing unusual: mule deer, fresh moose tracks in frozen mud, a distant coyote.
Then the radio crackled. The writer says the friend’s voice came through: “I hear you loud and clear. What’s up?”
Confused, the writer answered that everything was fine. After a long silence, they write, the friend’s tone changed: “I’m right here in my stand. You were yelling my name from the trees a second ago…”
“I wasn’t,” the writer insists. “I swear I wasn’t even pressing the transmit button on my radio.”
A voice in the trees
As the writer tells it, the friend became genuinely shaken. He said he could hear the writer’s voice calling his name from the trees only a few yards from his stand, in a weird tone, “like my accent but robotic.” He decided to abort, climbed down, and asked the writer to keep a rifle ready, whether for “forest ghosts” or a black bear or mountain lion.
At the truck, the writer says, the friend was “pale as a ghost and strangely quiet,” brushed off questions, blamed the cold for playing tricks on his ears, and insisted the writer drive, which the writer calls odd because he loves driving his own truck.
The drive home
On the dark mountain road, the writer says the friend barely blinked, his limbs looked rigid, and when oncoming headlights hit his face “he seemed taller than usual, almost brushing the roof of the cab.” The writer immediately offers ordinary explanations: the way he was sitting, the shadows, stiffness from hours in a stand.
At the friend’s house, he got out quickly with something like “Bad hunt, see you later.” Then comes the detail the writer says they only grasped later. The friend did not say the writer’s name. He used “the exact childhood nickname my grandfather used to call me when we went hunting together, a nickname I had never told a single soul, not even him.”
What we know
On the record: documents, statements, dates and places. Sources below.
- A first-person Reddit post dated November 12, 2026, describes an evening hunt in western Montana in about late October. No forest, mountain or town is named, and in the replies the writer declined to give the spot.
- No audio or other recording has been posted.
- The friend has not shared his own account. In the replies, the writer says the two “haven’t spoken much since then.”
What’s claimed
Accounts, testimony and theories, as told by the people who tell them.
- That a voice imitating the writer called the friend’s name. That is the friend’s experience as relayed by the writer, secondhand.
- That the friend looked taller in the cab. The writer offers shadow and posture explanations for this in the same breath.
- That the nickname was never shared. That rests on the writer’s memory, and it is the one detail the friend himself could clear up.
- The writer asks whether it was a prank, a cold-weather hallucination or something else. Commenters suggested a mimicking bird, a skinwalker, a spirit and a “Sasquatch” mimic. None of those readings is supported by anything beyond the story itself.
Where it started
The original Reddit post (opens in new tab) drew dozens of replies. One of the most practical suggested a bird such as a starling or mockingbird, which can mimic human speech. The writer, who says they are a lifelong hunter, answered that they have heard birds mimic things in the woods, including a raven repeating “I see you,” but doubted it would have panicked their friend. Another reply recommended simply talking to the friend, over drinks, about the nickname. A third summed up the thread: “The nickname part really gets to me.”
A few readers also said they found the story chilling “even if this is made up.” It is fair to note that a story this well paced reads like the campfire tales it echoes. Nothing in the post proves or disproves it.
One question left
Strip away the folklore and this account comes down to a conversation that has not happened yet. The friend heard something in the trees. The friend said something at the door. Only the friend can say what he heard, and where that nickname came from. Until he does, this is a haunting told from one side of the cab.
Sources
- My friend heard my voice in the Montana woods two weeks ago. Now some things just don’t add up. (opens in new tab) · u/ElMattew on r/Paranormal First-person account posted November 12, 2026, describing an evening about two weeks earlier. The friend has not posted.