The Whimpering Howler: A Sound That Follows a Dog Walker to the End of a Youngstown Street
A Youngstown, Ohio, Reddit user says something has been making a whimpering, rising howl near their dead end street for a couple of years, and that this week it sounded deeper, like two of them, and seemed to follow the poster and their dogs. They're trying to record it.
Location Youngstown, Ohio

YOUNGSTOWN, Ohio (Oct. 20, 2026): Four in the morning is dog walking time on the poster’s street. Their husband leaves for work, and they take out the three of them: two German shepherds and a husky lab mix. The street is a dead end, and at the end of it is a trailhead into the park.
Where it started
The original social media post
-
u/Threeshepherds on Reddit
it sounded kind of like a dog whimpering but with an increase in the pitch like it was something trying to howl but not quite getting it right or maybe something injured.
Trimmed from a longer first-hand post.
25 points · 7 comments as of Oct 24, 2026
From the conversation
-
Ohio is chock FULL of them, with sightings increasing. One of the scariest I’be ever heard took place in Youngstown in the 1980-90s.
-
Of you didn't have a clue you wouldn't have posted here. Be safe.
-
I don't know what it is which is why I said I don't have a clue. It could be dogman but I've not seen the thing.
-
Posts shown as originally published; we don’t verify individual comments. Retrieved . “Load the post here” fetches the original from Reddit, which may set cookies.
For a couple of years now, they wrote on Reddit this week, something out there has been making a sound they can’t place. And the last few mornings, it’s changed.
What’s claimed
Accounts, testimony and theories, as told by the people who tell them.
The poster, who writes as Threeshepherds on r/dogman, says they first heard it “very late one night” with a window open.
- The first sound. “At first I thought it was a wonky siren of some sort but as I listened closer I noticed it sounded kind of like a dog whimpering but with an increase in the pitch like it was something trying to howl but not quite getting it right or maybe something injured.”
- The timing. They noticed it around the time their mother came to stay, they write, and their mother has since moved away again. It turns up “late at night early in the mornings.”
- It moves away. One morning they went into the backyard of the empty house next door to try to see it. “It seemed like it got further away the closer I got to it but you couldn’t hear footsteps or movement.”
- It got deeper. In the last couple of mornings, they say, it sounded “very different like a deeper gutteral vocal.” And, “I SWEAR this morning I hear two of them!”
- It followed. On their walk, “it sounded like it was following me and my dogs to the end of the street.”
What we know
On the record: documents, statements, dates and places. Sources below.
This is a single first-hand account, with no recording yet. “I will keep trying to get a recording,” they write. They don’t give an exact street, and we haven’t tried to identify it.
Threeshepherds says they have ruled things out, and they know their animals. “I am very familiar with recognizable wildlife because I’m from Appalachia.” Their list: “I know it isn’t an owl of any type I know it isn’t a fox or coyote definitely not a bear or deer.”
They posted to a dogman forum, but they’re careful about it. When a commenter suggested they knew more than they were saying, they replied: “I don’t know what it is which is why I said I don’t have a clue. It could be dogman but I’ve not seen the thing.” They say they saw a dogman years ago, but that one “didn’t make any noises,” and that nobody they’ve heard from describes “whimpering howling sounds. Howls and growls yes but nothing like this.”
The sound question
Late-night animal sounds are notoriously hard to identify, even for people who know the woods. Foxes scream. Coyote pups yip and wail in ways that sound nothing like adults. Owls whinny. Raccoons fighting can sound like a person in distress. And a sound that seems to move away as you approach can be an animal staying just out of sight, or an echo off houses and trees in a ravine.
Threeshepherds has ruled out owls, foxes and coyotes, and may well be right. A recording is what would let someone else check. Wildlife biologists and birders can often identify a call from a few seconds of audio.
The Youngstown connection
The poster isn’t the first person to tie Youngstown to a dogman story. A commenter, MissGoldie71, pointed to a well-known account: “One of the scariest I’be ever heard took place in Youngstown in the 1980-90s,” naming a man who now hosts a YouTube channel about the subject. The poster said they knew the story and had heard him speak at a paranormal convention.
What’s next
If they get the recording, we’d like to hear it, and so would anyone who knows animal calls. If it surfaces, we’ll update this story.
Sources
- The Whimpering Howler (opens in new tab) · Reddit, r/dogman First-hand account posted Oct. 20, 2026.